‹ Back

Why your teen ignores you when you ask about school 

 

 

Abstract: 

 

• Brain science: Teens’ prefrontal cortex still developing → struggle with immediate reflection.

• Emotional load: School is mentally draining; small talk feels like an exam at the end of the day.

• Default autopilot: “Fine” is the shield against interrogation fatigue.

• Misread signals: Silence ≠ defiance; it’s a decompression mechanism.

• Parent trap: Asking at the wrong time (doorway, car ride, while hungry/tired).

• Alternative strategy: Delay—wait until they’re fed/rested before checking in.

• Better questions: Ask specific, low-pressure ones (“What made you laugh today?” / “What was the weirdest thing in class?”).

• Agency: Give them space to initiate conversation.

• Consistency: Regular, calm curiosity builds trust—don’t force disclosure.

• Big picture: Shift from “daily report” to “building relationship capital.”

Have you ever wondered what goes through your child's mind when you ask them about school and most often you are met with sighs, grunts, and "I dunno, okay I guess"?

 

As I have worked with teenagers pretty much my whole life, I can assure you that there is a complexity hidden beneath the surface, but that there are some barriers between your intention and their delivery. Let's break it down.

 

While thinking of this article, a few ideas have come to mind, and using my trusty AI, I have developed a slew of questions that could assist us in understanding the nuances of this sullen and chaotic age group. And in the age of identities being formed in the collective, we do sometimes expect them to be human, not considering that they are not treated as such.

 

Now, before we get into the crux of the matter, let's refer to the biology lesson some of us would rather skip: The brain (and then we get to the reason you are here). The brain is a fantastic organ. Fun Fact: The brain stem is exactly the same as a shark's brain (which, very interestingly, is a justification for the theory of Evolution). However, something the human brain has that is unique to our evolution is that we have the big dome-shaped-thingy that protects the even more sensitive and squishy insides (breathing, swallowing, balance, you know … the functions that keep us alive).

 

The cortex is comprised of two hemispheres: The left and right, that is connected via the corpus collosum. The development of the brain is usually complete by the age of approximately 25 years old, which is why most of your cringe moments of "oh, what was I thinking" occurred before then (you weren't stupid per se, you were just young and not fully capable of making lifelong regret preventing decisions. Nonetheless, there are four parts of the cortex, namely: Prefrontal Lobe (Planning, decision-making, impulse control, movement), Parietal Lobe (Sensory processing (touch, spatial awareness, navigation)), Temporal Lobe (Hearing, memory, language comprehension), and Occipital Lobe (Vision and visual processing).

 

 

 

However, because the brain of a teen is still developing, they do tend to have delayed responses to questions, and may need time to process the question that is being asked. Oftentimes, I will notice that a teen is processing a query, but immediately the parent will jump in and ask another question or will start making a judgement on their character. Being counterintuitive, there is no presence of silence awaiting a response, so they tend to not. While working with teens, you will often hear me asking a question and then patiently waiting for a response, no matter how poorly their point is verbalised. You'll hear me say: No, 'I don't know' is not an answer I'm happy to accept. I really want to know. So take the time to think and then I'll be happy to listen". If they respond with: "But I don't know how to say what I'm thinking", then I will respond with: "it's okay, let me help you figure out the words to use so you can convey meaning - just do it badly and I'll guide you". Most times you will find that the child just has no language development.

 

Segway: And I hear you saying: "But shouldn't the schools be teaching this?". No. The schools are teaching the curriculum. Maybe that's why they're falling between the cracks because they did not learn how to use language in the three minutes they were given to practice and obviously they have no idea what it means to work outside of an adult telling them to (schools also don't teach initiative or self-determination either). There's no time for a teacher to sit and figure out if all 40 children can string three words together to form a coherent sentence. Chances are, if this had to become standardised practice, they'd drug far more children than they already are (when meds a child is taking has the words 'thousands of rands per month', you are not seeing a doctor - you are funding a drug dealer). Anywho.

 

Another reason: Have you ever come home from work and just want the world to stfu and every word feels like nails on a chalkboard? Or you are emotional because your boss climbed down your throat for something out of your control? Oooo, or what about the times you're stressing about not having enough money or not being successful enough in terms of title that you become forlorn and feel like you've wasted your life? With all due respect, newsflash babes, your kid feels the same way. Not everyone wants to talk about their day in excruciating detail. And oftentimes, if your child is telling you things, it's because that's the highlights they are telling you to get you off their back. Harsh truths - boom. These types of questions may feel like an exam at the end of the day (which they dread, because now it's another performance act their self-worth is going to be tied to).

 

By using the word 'fine' when asked about their day could also be an indication of interrogation fatigue. Every day these kids are inundated with rules and shouting and commands and lectures. The only reason you are touting the schools name is because you've never had an actual conversation with your traumatised child as to what ACTUALLY goes on within the school walls. I have these conversations, and let me tell you, it's bad. The kids aren't committing suicide or being institutionalised because it's eutopia and they're just weak.

 

Furthermore, a teen shutting down after an emotionally taxing day does not mean that they are being defiant. The silence could be their way of decompressing. Some parents have their wine or coffee or smokes. Your kid has you screaming at them in the mornings and evenings, and a bunch of unhappy, unfulfilled, overworked adults who are outnumbered by evil little gremlins who make you believe in corporal punishment (hey, let the cops do it? Just a good bam bam bam on the bum and whoop, order - but noooo).

 

Another reason why your child might shut down when asked these questions is because the question isn't just a question. Gosh, if it was, maybe they'd squeak out a giggle or crack open a smile they forgot they had. No, no. The timing is often not well-placed - in the doorway, in front of friends, on the car ride home, during supper - but never during one on one time when the topic of school comes into the conversation naturally. Perhaps I'm saying that you're not spending quality time with your child, so maybe that's why you don't have a relationship with them? You don't come to me to get your ears tickled. You asked what's wrong. Here's how you fix it. You're welcome. If you just bit my head off …. Yes, that's why your kid is afraid to live in your presence.

 

Sometimes the timing is also wrong because it is when there's hunger, tiredness, overwhelm, or when either participant is in a foul mood. Have you any idea how many times I would open my door to a child hysterically crying (mostly girls) because the parent decided that the car ride - while they were entertaining a temper - was THE moment to tell them exactly how they regret having them. Not on, hey. Advice for this one: 1) Calm down, you are the adult. 2) Maybe consider getting some food, going to sit by the lake, taking some time to look up at the sky and remember that you are teaching them how to handle their emotions in this very moment. 3) Try to understand why they are doing what they are doing and just for a moment, pretend to be a leader by vaguely attempting to solve the problem rather than resort to tactics that make them (and the people who work with them) resent you (it's not fair to load a crying child off onto someone else who actually has a job on top of having to baby sit a sullen teenager - thanks).

 

Moreover, perhaps try different types of questions. There's a concept known as open and closed questions: Closed question: How was your day (possible responses: fine/okay), what did you do today (possible responses: nothing / nothing much), did you learn anything / have fun (possible responses: yes/no). Perhaps spice it up with some open questions like: What made you laugh today? What was the weirdest thing in class? Does that boy still smell like cheese and onion chips with cream cheese in the neckline? I don't know - be creative. It's your child.

 

Another tactic can be to allow silence. Let them initiate the conversation. So? You'll go for a few days without talking to them. It's not like you don't go days without talking to your parents. Pot, meet kettle. Let them come to you. But don't have an issue or bash or slam or throw things. Hum, dance, go sit outside for five minutes not begrudging life because you didn't end up with the kid you wanted (Yes, I'm salty because I work with these kids and I have consoled many tears of kids who have said: I don't know why my parents don't love me). By being calm, consistent and regular, you are building trust. But don't force it. It's like a cat - make them love you, they run. Ignore them, they'll join in on the fun (it rhymes).

 

Consider shifting from daily check-in's and reporting to building relationship capital - you know, the kind that will see the investment yield compound interest in their 20's and 30's. A lot of what you need to do now is strategy (and that's why you come to your favourite Psychoacademic Strategist - me). They are brighter than you know, and demand leadership for respect to be given. If you want a place in their hearts, remember what it was like when you were a teen without those rose coloured glasses. It sucks. And sometimes, you're making it worse by not understanding that they are just normal people riddled with potential and self-doubt, like the rest of us mere mortals.

 

In the end, all I want is for these kids to have stable lives so that they can grow to become semi-okay adults with limited damage. I want them to have that relationship with you that you and they deserve. And from what I can see, it comes down to communication and emotion regulation. You can't expect them to speak to you if you don't know how to speak to them. And you can't expect them to control their emotions if all you do is lay into them for not being who you want them to be.

 

 

Nothing will change unless you model change. And here’s the kicker: you can’t do that without data. The next time you hear yourself asking the same tired question, stop. Watch. Collect the data like a scientist, and make sense of it. We live in the age of information—if you can’t figure this out, who will?